Back to the blog

Transfer the call or take a message: how to decide

Which calls should ring a person and which should end in a message. A simple rule set for transfers, staff job titles, fallback numbers and what happens when nobody picks up.

By Robofono team

5 min read

When an AI phone agent cannot or should not finish a call itself, it has 2 options: connect the caller to a person, or take a message. Choosing the wrong one costs you either way. Transfer too much and your team is interrupted all day. Take messages when you should have transferred and a hot customer waits.

You can decide this once, write it down and let the agent apply it. This guide gives you a way to decide.

What each option does

A transfer rings a person you named: a staff member or a team line. The caller waits, then talks to a human. It is fast and personal, and it needs someone to be there.

A message is a short record: who called, how to reach them and what they want. The owner receives it right away, and you can read it in the call list with the summary and transcript. It needs no one to be available, and it needs someone to follow up.

The transfers feature lets the agent reach staff or a team line, and the agent takes a message when nobody can be reached. So you do not have to choose one for a whole call. You choose a first option and a second.

4 questions to sort any call

Ask these in order about each type of call.

1. Is it urgent?

Urgent means waiting hurts the caller or the business: a water leak, a patient in pain, a car stranded on a forecourt. Urgent calls should try a transfer first. If the transfer fails, take a message marked urgent and make sure someone reads it quickly.

2. Is it valuable and time-sensitive?

A buyer calling about a viewing today, or a regular customer with a large order, often prefers speaking to a person. If someone is in, transfer. If not, book a callback time that you can keep.

3. Does it need a judgement the agent should not make?

Complaints, exceptions, price negotiations, medical questions and anything where a wrong answer causes harm belong with people. The agent should not decide them. Transfer when someone is there, take a message when not, and do not let the agent improvise an answer.

4. Can the agent finish it?

Opening hours, directions, a simple booking and "where is my order" often can be finished by the agent with no one else involved. Do not transfer these. A transfer for a question the agent could answer wastes a person's time.

A starting rule set

You can adjust this, but it is a good first draft:

Call During hours After hours
Routine question Agent answers Agent answers
Booking Agent books Agent books
Urgent problem Transfer to the right person; message if no answer Transfer to on-call; message marked urgent if no answer
Caller asks for a named person or role Transfer to that person; message if no answer Message
Complaint or sensitive matter Transfer; message if no answer Message
Sales call or wrong number End politely End politely

Paste the logic into the agent's instructions in plain sentences. See write instructions your AI phone agent will follow for how.

Let callers ask for a role

Callers rarely know names. They ask for "the hygienist", "someone about my invoice" or "the person who does colour". Give staff job titles, and the agent can match the request to the right person. For bookings, the same titles route the caller to the right calendar. Keep the titles in the words your callers use, not internal ones.

Decide who is on the transfer list

A transfer list is only as good as its numbers. Check these:

  • Each person's number is current. Update it when someone leaves, changes phone or goes on holiday.
  • A team line beats a single person when you can have one. If one person misses the call, another can pick up.
  • Hours match. Do not transfer to someone who is off. The agent can only follow the hours you set.
  • Order is clear. Write which person is tried first.

If you use day and after-hours routing, set a different list for each period.

Plan for the transfer that fails

Phones go unanswered. Decide what happens next and write it into the instructions:

If the transfer is not answered, apologise once, take a message with the caller's name, number and reason, and say that someone will respond. Do not say when.

The last sentence matters. Promising "within 10 minutes" is a debt you may not be able to pay.

Also set a fallback number for the case where the AI is switched off, so callers reach a person or a voicemail, not a dead line.

What makes a good message

A message is only useful if you can act on it. Tell the agent what to capture:

  1. The caller's name.
  2. The best phone number.
  3. What they need, in their own words.
  4. How urgent it is, if the caller says.
  5. For bookings, the day they hoped for.

Keep it to these. Every extra question lengthens the call. The summary and the transcript are in the call list if you need more.

Measure and adjust

After the first 2 weeks, read the calls that ended in a transfer and the ones that ended in a message. Ask 3 things:

  • Were any transfers for questions the agent could have answered? Add that answer to the knowledge.
  • Were any messages for calls that deserved a transfer? Tighten the rule for urgent or valuable calls.
  • Did any call end with the caller waiting too long? Change the list or the order.

Transfers that your team dreads are a sign the agent is passing on too much. Messages that nobody reads are a sign the process after the call is missing. Both are fixable in the instructions and the list.

Where it matters

Every industry has its own mix. See how it looks for clinics, real estate and home services. To test your rules, start a 7-day FREE trial with 10 minutes and no payment up front, and use the browser test call to try each case in the table. See the pricing page for the plans after the trial.

More from the blog

Let Robofono answer your next call

Set up an AI phone agent in minutes. 7-day FREE trial, no credit card required.

7-day FREE trial, no credit card required. Nothing is charged unless you add a card.